| Year | Name |
|---|---|
| 2025 | Garry Gilliam |
| 2024 | Reggie White |
| 2023 | Bo Orlando |
| 2022 | Henry Hynoski |
| 2021 | Todd Rucci |
| 2020 | Coy Wire |
| 2019 | Bruce Clark |
| 2018 | Scott Campbell |
| 2017 | Jordan Hill, Steve Keim, Noah Spence & Bob Watson, Sr. |
| 2016 | Jared Odrick |
| 2015 | Vaughn Hebron |
| 2014 | Marques Colston |
| 2013 | Antonio Freeman |
| 2012 | Ben Roethlisberger |
| 2011 | Ty Law |
| 2010 | Ricky Watters |
| 2009 | Kyle Brady |
| 2008 | Todd Blackledge |
| 2007 | Marty Schottenheimer |
| 2006 | Bill Fralic |
| 2005 | Raghib “Rocket” Ismail |
| 2004 | Matt Millen |
| 2003 | Dan Marino |
| 2002 | Dave Wannstedt & Jeff Hostetler |
| 2001 | Joe Montana |
| 2000 | Jim Kelly |
| 1999 | Blair Thomas |
| 1998 | James Jones |
| 1997 | Herb Adderley |
| 1996 | Jim Covert |
| 1995 | Tim Lewis |
| 1994 | John Cappelletti |
| 1993 | Matt Millen |
| 1992 | Ted Kwalick |
| 1991 | Pete Duranko |
| 1990 | Tony Dorsett |
| 1989 | Jim Nance |
| 1988 | Jimmy Cefalo |
| 1987 | Matt Suhey |
| 1986 | Mickey Shuler |
